Introduction

Every great story begins with a call to adventure—a moment when ordinary life is shattered, and the hero must choose whether to step forward or remain in the shadows. 1923, the Yellowstone prequel, is more than a Western drama; it is a masterclass in the Hero’s Journey, brought to life through the struggles and triumphs of the Dutton family and those around them. As creative leaders, we are invited not only to witness their story but to reflect on the narratives we craft about ourselves. Are we the heroes of our own lives, or do we let circumstance write our legend for us?

Plot Summary: The Duttons’ Odyssey

Set in the turbulent early 20th century, 1923 follows Jacob and Cara Dutton as they fight to protect their Montana ranch from economic hardship, lawlessness, and the relentless advance of modernity. Their nephew, Spencer Dutton, haunted by the trauma of World War I, embarks on his own odyssey—first as a big game hunter in Africa, then on a perilous journey home, spurred by love and duty.

Meanwhile, Teonna Rainwater, a young Crow woman, escapes the brutality of a boarding school, forging her own path to freedom in the face of relentless pursuit and violence5. The Duttons’ battle with rival ranchers, led by Banner Creighton, escalates into tragedy and bloodshed, testing the family’s resolve and unity. Through heartbreak, sacrifice, and moments of grace, the Duttons and their allies must decide what they are willing to risk—and who they are willing to become—to protect what matters most.

The Hero’s Journey and 12 Archetypes in “1923”

Hero’s Journey Series

Ordinary World The Duttons’ ranch life before the storm of conflict.

Call to Adventure Jacob’s confrontation with Creighton; Cara’s plea to Spencer to return home.

Refusal of the Call Spencer’s reluctance to leave his life abroad and face old wounds.

Meeting the Mentor Cara’s wisdom and resilience; Alexandra’s encouragement for Spencer.

Crossing the Threshold Spencer’s decision to journey back to Montana.

Tests, Allies, Enemies Battles with Creighton, betrayals, and new alliances; Teonna’s escape.

Approach the Inmost Cave The Duttons’ last stand; Teonna’s fight for survival.

Ordeal Loss, violence, and near defeat—testing every character’s limits.

Reward Hard-won survival, moments of peace, and new beginnings.

The Road Back The Duttons regroup, facing the consequences of their choices.

Resurrection Spencer’s transformation; Teonna’s hope for a new life.

Return with the Elixir Wisdom, legacy, and the promise of a future for the next generation.

Moments of Reflection: The Story You Tell Yourself

As you watch 1923, consider:

• When have you, like Spencer or Teonna, faced a call to adventure that demanded everything of you?
• Do you recognize the mentors and allies in your life, or do you try to walk the path alone?
• What shadows or adversaries challenge your progress—and do they come from outside, or within?
• Are you consciously crafting your legend, or letting others define your story?

You are the storyteller of your own life. Every hardship, every triumph, every moment of doubt is a chapter in your legend. Like the Duttons, you can choose to rise, to transform, to return with wisdom for those who follow.

Conclusion

1923 is a sweeping epic of loss and resilience, but above all, it is a meditation on the power of story. The Duttons, Teonna, and their allies show us that legends are not born—they are forged in the crucible of adversity, choice, and courage. As creative leaders, we must ask: Are we living by default, or by design? Are we the heroes of our own journey, or mere bystanders in our own lives?

Questions to Take Away as a Creative Leader

• What is the story you tell yourself about who you are and what you can achieve?
• Where in your life are you being called to adventure, but resisting the call?
• Who are your mentors, allies, and adversaries—and how do they shape your journey?
• What legacy do you want to leave for those who come after you?
• How can you transform adversity into the elixir that enriches your own legend—and inspires others?

Remember: You are the hero, the storyteller, and the legend in the making. The next chapter is yours to write.

— Peter de Kuster