---

Patrice Leconte’s Monsieur  Hire is not a whodunit. It is a tragedy about loneliness, longing, and the way desire can turn into both devotion and doom. It begins with a corpse — a woman dead in the rain — and circles back to the living ghosts who remain behind.

Monsieur Hire is a small, pale, balding tailor, a man so exact in his habits that time itself seems pressed and steamed around his suits. Across the courtyard lives Alice, twenty‑two, golden‑haired, open‑hearted — a young woman who seems to radiate what he has never dared to ask for. Two solitary people in separate rooms, joined by a line of sight.

What happens in your story when looking replaces living?
How often have you loved from the distance of safety, because stepping closer would ruin the dream?

The Outsider in the Courtyard

On the night of the murder, witnesses see a small man running toward Hire’s building. The police arrive, collecting gossip and glances. No one likes Hire. Even he agrees. “I seem to strike people oddly,” he says, half‑defensive, half‑resigned. When a neighbor eyes him through the crack of a door, he offers, “Want a photo?”

He is mocked, powdered from windows above, whitened like an unwanted statue. His black suit is too perfect, his demeanor too silent, his difference too visible. Michel  Blanc plays him with a precision bordering on pain — every gesture tidy, every emotion ironed flat.

Where in your own life have you been the person others find “odd,” simply because you refused to play their part?
What armor have you built around your difference?

The Watcher

Alice, in contrast, embodied by Sandrine  Bonnaire, is everything he is not — spontaneous, radiant, alive in color. When lightning flashes one night, she glimpses the shape in the window opposite: Hire, standing still in the darkness, watching her as if she were the only source of light left in his world. He watches her endlessly — dressing, ironing, sleeping, making love with her rough boyfriend  Émile (Luc  Thuillier).

What does it mean to observe life instead of joining it?
Whom do you watch when you think nobody sees you watching?

The Color of Desire

Leconte fills Hire’s world with monochrome. Blacks and whites. Gray streets. White mice in little cages in his shop — creatures as restrained and nervous as their keeper. Even his skin seems translucent, untouched by the sun.

Alice, however, lives in color. She wears red dresses, red lipstick, carries bags of ripe red tomatoes that spill down the staircase toward him like droplets of invitation. Does Hire stoop to help her? No. He simply watches, uncertain whether this grace is accident or trap.

When love approaches you in full color, do you help it gather its fallen pieces — or stand frozen in awe?
Does fear of contamination keep you from tasting what is real?

The Knock

Alice knocks on his door one morning. He does not answer. The next day she returns, persistent. This time he lets her in — not to his apartment, but into the world of his solitude. He invites her to a restaurant in a train station, a place of transience and departures.

There, he confesses: yes, he has seen her in her bedroom. Yes, he has watched her with her lover. But he also claims to know something else — something about the murder that hovers over them both.

Her friendliness, he believes, hides another motive. And yet, when she listens to him, her face softens. What began as fear and pity grows into something more dangerous: understanding.

What happens in your story when someone truly sees you — your tenderness, your obsession, your shame — and doesn’t turn away?
Is it love, redemption, or the start of collapse?

The Lover and the Lout

Émile, Alice’s boyfriend, is the blunt counterpoint to Hire’s precision: muscular, careless, thoughtless. His idea of romance is a boxing match. When he needs to flee, he uses Alice’s body as a ladder — first stepping into her clasped hands, then on her shoulders. In that gesture, Leconte compresses everything about their relationship: she carries the weight; he never notices the pain.

Who in your story has used your devotion as their escape route?
How many times have you mistaken being needed for being loved?

Sharing Secrets

When Alice finally visits Hire’s apartment, he tells her things no one else knows. He speaks calmly about his visits to prostitutes — describing the ritual, the scent, the performance of intimacy. Alice listens, fascinated, perhaps even aroused by the unexpected sensuality beneath his pallor. But then he says he can never return to them. He has fallen in love with her.

It is the most dangerous truth he could utter, because it carries not invitation but prophecy.

What truth about your desire have you silenced for fear it might destroy the fragile order of your life?
And what might be born if you were brave enough to speak it?

The Illusion of Acceptance

Even in his isolation, Hire has a secret stage. One evening, he takes the investigating inspector to a bowling alley. There, in front of laughing regulars, he performs trick shots with magician‑like ease — strikes blindfolded, strikes between his legs. The applause warms him for a moment. “You see?” he tells the policeman. “I’m not disliked everywhere.”

It is both boast and plea. We glimpse the child still begging to be invited to play.

When was the last time you performed competence to earn care?
What applause do you still chase because silence feels like abandonment?

The Web of Deception

What, truly, is happening between Hire and Alice? What does she feel? Compassion, pity, attraction, guilt? And what does she seek from her boyfriend Émile — protection or punishment?

As in classic film noir, their fates twist around secrecy and projection. Each sees in the other what they most long for and least understand. Hire’s love is absolute because it is imagined. Alice’s affection flickers between manipulation and tenderness. Her devotion to Émile seems misguided, her connection to Hire tragic yet pure.

In your story, who symbolizes your longing for innocence?
Whom do you keep loving against all logic, as if suffering itself were proof of sincerity?

The Slow Spiral Toward Tragedy

At the center of Monsieur  Hire lies the ache of misconnection — two people circling each other like planets whose orbits never quite align. As the investigation closes in, the pace quickens. There is a moment near the end, filmed in fast motion, that slows suddenly, allowing a single heartbreaking image to linger — the kind of detail that defines a lifetime.

Then comes the ending: inevitable, cruel, unsatisfying. It closes the plot but opens a wound. Loneliness, once exposed, cannot simply be solved; it must be faced.

What is the moment in your story that slows your racing life to a single unbearable truth?
When the curtain falls, do you want justice — or connection?

Your Story in the Mirror

Leconte, adapting Georges  Simenon’s Monsieur  Hire’s  Engagement, replaces the usual Maigret intrigue with psychological intimacy. Simenon’s elegant simplicity finds visual expression in Leconte’s controlled direction — every line, every color, a clue to character. The director uses restraint not as absence but as precision, as if emotion itself could be tailored.

Like Hire’s suits, the film is immaculate; like his heart, it hides a tremor in every seam.

And so you, watching it, become the third character in the courtyard — the unseen observer witnessing two lives that echo your own. The film does not ask whether Hire is guilty of murder. It asks whether any of us are innocent of hunger, projection, or fear.

Where does solitude end and obsession begin in your life?
When have you mistaken being noticed for being loved?
What truth are you still afraid the light of another window might reveal?

Monsieur  Hire leaves us with no villains, only humans: a man who wants to be seen, a woman who wants to be understood, and a world that notices too late the quiet disasters happening behind closed curtains.

Tell your story before silence does it for you.

Because every watcher is, eventually, also watched.